If your Englewood home would rent for $1,800–$2,400 a month — realistic for a 3-bedroom near South Broadway or Hampden Avenue — renting out usually beats selling if you can hold the asset for at least three to five years. Sell instead if you need cash now, can't cover a mortgage gap, or face a capital-gains window that closes soon.
Englewood sits in one of the tightest rental corridors in the South Denver metro. Proximity to light rail at the Englewood Station on the C and D lines, walkable retail along South Broadway, and easy access to Denver proper via US-285 and I-25 mean tenant demand stays strong even when the broader market softens. That demand is exactly what makes the rent-versus-sell question genuinely difficult — both paths have real merit, so the decision comes down to your personal finances, tax situation, and appetite for being a landlord.
What can I actually rent my Englewood house for right now?
A typical 3-bedroom, 1–2 bath single-family home in Englewood rents for $1,900–$2,300 per month as of mid-2024, with updated properties near Belleview Park or the walkable South Broadway corridor pushing toward $2,400. Smaller 2-bedroom units or garden-level condos near Cinderella City's redeveloped footprint (now CityCenter Englewood) run $1,500–$1,800.
PMI Little Town offers a free rental analysis that benchmarks your specific address against active listings and recently signed leases in Englewood — not just ZIP-code averages pulled from a national database. That distinction matters on a street like South Elati or West Floyd Avenue where block-by-block condition and parking availability swing rents by $150 or more.
Before you commit to either path, get that number in writing. It anchors every other calculation in this article — your gross yield, your cash flow after management fees, and the break-even point against a sale.
What would my actual monthly cash flow look like after all the costs?
On a $2,000 rent with no mortgage, your net operating income after PMI Little Town's 8% monthly management fee ($160) and a vacancy reserve of roughly 5% ($100) is about $1,740 per month — before property taxes, insurance, and maintenance. Englewood's 2024 residential property tax rate is approximately 6.765 mills on assessed value, which for a $450,000 home works out to roughly $175–$225 per month depending on your assessment.
Add a maintenance reserve of 1% of home value annually (about $375/month on a $450,000 property) and landlord insurance averaging $100–$150/month, and a free-and-clear owner might net $1,100–$1,300 per month. If you're carrying a mortgage at a pre-2022 rate under 4%, those numbers likely still cash-flow positive. If you refinanced at 7% and owe $380,000, your PITI alone may exceed rent — in which case selling deserves a hard look.
The leasing fee of 50% of the first month's rent — roughly $1,000 on a $2,000 rental — is a one-time cost paid when a tenant is placed. Lease renewals cost 25% of one month's rent (about $500), and many tenants in desirable Englewood neighborhoods renew for two or three years, keeping that fee infrequent.
What are the tax consequences of selling versus renting in Colorado?
If you lived in the home as your primary residence for at least two of the last five years, you can exclude up to $250,000 in capital gains ($500,000 if married filing jointly) under IRS Section 121 — but that exclusion disappears once you convert the home to a rental and the two-of-five-year window closes. If your Englewood home has appreciated significantly since you bought it on South Bannock Street in 2015, selling before that window closes could save you tens of thousands in federal tax.
Renting, on the other hand, lets you depreciate the structure over 27.5 years under IRS rules, sheltering a portion of rental income from taxes each year. On a $450,000 home where $360,000 is allocated to the structure, that's roughly $13,000 in annual depreciation — a meaningful deduction for most landlords.
Inherited properties get a stepped-up cost basis to fair market value at the date of death under IRC Section 1014, which often eliminates the capital-gains concern entirely for inherited homes. If you inherited your Englewood property, talk to a CPA before assuming you have a tax problem — you may have very little gain to report even if you sell tomorrow. Colorado also follows federal capital-gains treatment and taxes long-term gains at ordinary income rates up to 4.4% at the state level.
What Colorado landlord laws do I need to know before I rent it out?
Colorado's landlord-tenant law requires you to return a security deposit within 30 days of a tenancy ending (or 60 days if the lease specifies it), per C.R.S. § 38-12-103. Failing to meet that deadline — or improperly withholding deductions — can expose you to triple damages plus attorney's fees, so proper move-out documentation is non-negotiable.
Colorado also enacted the Residential Tenants Health and Safety Act (C.R.S. § 38-12-503), which gives tenants the right to withhold rent or repair-and-deduct for habitability failures. As an Englewood landlord, you're responsible for maintaining the property in a safe and habitable condition regardless of what a lease says. This isn't onerous for a well-maintained home, but it does mean deferred maintenance on the furnace or roof needs to be addressed before you place a tenant.
For ending a month-to-month tenancy, Colorado requires a minimum of 21 days' written notice for tenancies of 6 months or less, scaling up to 91 days for tenancies of 3 years or more under the 2019 amendments to C.R.S. § 13-40-107. Englewood has no additional city-specific rent control or just-cause eviction ordinance as of this writing, which gives landlords meaningful flexibility that some neighboring Denver neighborhoods no longer have.
How do I evaluate whether the Englewood rental market is likely to stay strong?
Englewood's rental demand rests on three durable pillars: light rail access, employment density, and housing cost relative to Denver proper. The C and D lines at Englewood Station connect tenants to downtown Denver in under 20 minutes, Swedish Medical Center on South University Boulevard employs thousands of healthcare workers who prefer to rent near work, and Englewood home purchase prices — averaging $450,000–$550,000 for a detached single-family in 2024 — push many would-be buyers into renting instead.
The City of Englewood's ongoing investment in its CityCenter mixed-use district and the redevelopment activity along South Broadway between Hampden and Yale continue to attract younger professionals and small families who value walkability. Vacancy rates for well-maintained single-family rentals in Englewood have consistently run below 5% over the past three years, meaning a quality property priced correctly typically leases within two to three weeks.
One risk worth naming honestly: if interest rates drop significantly and purchase affordability improves, some current renters will transition to buyers. That would soften demand somewhat but is unlikely to collapse it given Englewood's location advantage and constrained land for new single-family construction.
What are the clearest signs I should just sell instead of rent?
Sell if any of the following are true: you need the equity to fund another purchase or pay off debt within 12 months; the property requires more than $30,000 in deferred maintenance or code updates before it's rentable; you're outside the Section 121 exclusion window and face a large taxable gain; or you have no interest in being a landlord and no budget to hire a manager.
Also consider selling if the home is in a condition that would attract only lower-tier tenants or require a rent discount that eliminates your cash flow. A dated kitchen or single-car garage on a street like West Jefferson Avenue isn't a dealbreaker, but a failing foundation, outdated electrical panel, or non-permitted addition can create liability that outweighs the income potential.
Finally, think honestly about your emotional connection to the home. If the property was a family member's longtime residence and managing it would be emotionally difficult, that's a legitimate reason to sell. No spreadsheet captures the cost of ongoing stress.
Whether your Englewood home is a recently inherited property near Belleview Park or a house you moved out of when you relocated for work, the rent-versus-sell decision deserves more than a gut feeling — it deserves real numbers from someone who knows the South Broadway corridor and the Englewood rental market firsthand. PMI Little Town can walk you through a free rental analysis, model your projected cash flow, and help you understand exactly what managing that property would look like from day one. Give us a call at 720.358.8307 or visit littletonpropertymanagementinc.com to get started — there's no pressure, just a straightforward conversation about what makes sense for your situation.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does it take to find a tenant for a house in Englewood?
A well-priced, move-in-ready Englewood rental typically leases within 14–21 days. Properties near the Englewood light rail station or South Broadway with updated kitchens and baths often receive applications within the first week. Overpricing by even $100–$150 per month can extend vacancy to 45 days or more.What is the security deposit limit in Colorado?
Colorado does not cap security deposits by statute for residential leases, so landlords can set the deposit at any amount — though one to two months' rent is standard in Englewood. Deposits must be returned within 30 days of move-out (or 60 days if the lease specifies), with an itemized written statement for any deductions, per C.R.S. § 38-12-103.What does PMI Little Town charge to manage a rental in Englewood?
PMI Little Town charges 8% of monthly rent for ongoing management (about $160/month on a $2,000 rent), 50% of the first month's rent as a one-time leasing fee when a tenant is placed (~$1,000), and 25% of one month's rent for lease renewals (~$500). Rental analyses are free.Will I owe capital gains tax if I sell an inherited Englewood home?
Probably not much, if anything. Inherited properties receive a stepped-up cost basis to fair market value at the date of the original owner's death under IRC Section 1014. If you sell shortly after inheriting, your gain is typically minimal. Consult a CPA, but many heirs in this situation owe little or no federal capital-gains tax.Can I convert my former primary residence to a rental and still use the Section 121 exclusion later?
No. Once you convert the home to a rental, the clock on your two-of-five-year primary residence window keeps running but you stop accumulating qualifying time. If you've already lived there for two of the last five years and haven't converted yet, selling now captures the full exclusion — up to $250,000 single or $500,000 married. Wait too long after conversion and you lose it.Does Englewood have rent control or just-cause eviction requirements?
No. As of 2024, Englewood has not adopted local rent control or just-cause eviction ordinances. Colorado's 2019 preemption statute (C.R.S. § 38-12-301) also bars municipalities from enacting rent control, giving Englewood landlords the flexibility to adjust rents to market at lease renewal with appropriate notice.

